Why does the commandment to appoint a king depend on the people’s wishes?
The Netziv explains that different societies need different forms of government: one cannot tolerate a monarchy, while another cannot function without a king. Imposing an unsuitable form of rule can endanger lives, so appointing a king cannot be demanded unconditionally before the people agree. He uses this to explain the long period without a king while the Mishkan stood in Shiloh.
Quote from the source«ויש מדינה שבלא מלך הרי היא כספינה בלי קברניט.»
- Author
- הנצי"ב
- Source
- קול צופייך — קול צופייך — Noach 5787, p. 3
- Parsha
- Noach