Why did the Maharshal avoid fish on Rosh Hashanah even though it is considered a good sign?
The Magen Avraham reports that the Maharshal did not eat fish on Rosh Hashanah because he enjoyed its taste. The Maor V'shemesh explains that the effectiveness of a favorable sign depends on eating solely with the proper intention. The Maharshal therefore set aside this custom because of his enjoyment of the flavor.
Quote from the source«Since the Maharshal enjoyed the taste, he disregarded the minhag of eating fish on Rosh Hashana.»
- Author
- Maor V'shemesh
- Source
- Lemaan Yishmeu — 125 - Forgiving Another-2, p. 2