May I outbid someone who has already agreed to buy a house if the price is exceptionally low?
The article treats an exceptionally cheap purchase as a rare opportunity comparable to acquiring a hefker, or ownerless, item. Rashi extends the prohibition against taking an acquisition ahead of another person to hefker, while Rabbeinu Tam does not, because such an opportunity may not be available elsewhere. Under the ruling presented, which follows Rabbeinu Tam, Levi may buy the unusually cheap house ahead of Shimon. However, a baal nefesh seeking a higher standard of conduct should refrain, whether Shimon is poor or wealthy, because suitable real estate is not readily replaceable. The author adds that a final ruling for an individual situation should be obtained from one's rav.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«However, a baal nefesh should not jump ahead of Shimon’s purchasing the house.»
- Author
- Rabbi Moshe Gourarie
- Source
- Lemaan Yishmeu — 241 - The Path to Happiness, p. 2