Can a personal assurance from the Rebbe be applied to other occasions?
Reb Yitzchak Yoel related that at the Rebbe Rashab’s table he ate foods outside his prescribed diet after the Rebbe’s assurance and experienced no pain. When he repeated this at home the following Shabbos, he suffered severe pain and endangered his life. He concluded that the Rebbe’s assurance had applied only to that particular occasion.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«Evidently, the Rebbe assurance was for that time only…»
- Author
- Reb Yitzchak Yoel
- Source
- Lemaan Yishmeu — 260 - The Beauty of Modesty (4), p. 2