Why did Chacham Avuhav respond so strictly to a missed amen?
When Reb Mordechai Yaffa failed to answer amen to a child's blessing, Chacham Avuhav placed him under nidui and later required him to teach others the importance of answering amen. He told a story in which a righteous rabbi's brutal death is explained as punishment for once failing to answer amen to his son's blessing. The Chacham explained that his strict response was intended to provide atonement for his student.
Quote from the source«Now you understand why I became so upset and put you in a Nidui, for this was to be an atonement for you.»
- Author
- Chacham Avuhav
- Source
- Lemaan Yishmeu — 59 - Answering Amen, p. 1