Should one avoid zimun with people who recite Birkat Hamazon independently immediately after responding?
Tzitz Eliezer rules that one should not avoid such a zimun and finds grounds for considering it valid. Shevet Halevi explains that some people struggle to recite quietly while listening to the leader and consequently omit words. For those people, it is preferable to recite Birkat Hamazon completely aloud and rely for zimun on the views that consider the response sufficient.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«והשיב שאף שהקושי גדול, למעשה אין להימנע מלזמן, ויש מקום ללמד זכות שיוצאים ידי חובת זימון גם באופן זה.»
- Author
- ציץ אליעזר; שבט הלוי
- Source
- עומק הפשט — עומק הפשט — Noach 5787, p. 4
- Parsha
- Noach