When must a rabbi explain the grounds for a surprising permission?
The author cites a rule against a scholar issuing an unexplained permission that appears to people to permit something forbidden. In the Shach's explanation quoted there, the situation differs when the rabbi gives the questioner the reason for the ruling. The author also invokes the duty to remove suspicion of improper judgment and therefore calls for a substantive explanation rather than a bare statement that a known law does not apply.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«אבל אם א ומ ר לש ו א ל ט ע ם ב ד ב ר»
- Author
- הרב נחמ ן דו ידסון
- Source
- Kfar Chabad — 039, p. 11