Why does the author reject an ideological argument in the dispute over transferring territories?
The author quotes an unnamed rabbi who rejects applying Orach Chaim 329 to the territorial transfer under discussion and describes the opposing arguments as foreign to the spirit of tradition. The author himself considers that section applicable and objects that an ideological assessment does not explain the halachic distinction. He insists that a decision involving danger to life must have a halachic basis.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«א ין ש ום ש י יכ ות לע נ י נ נ ו»
- Author
- הרב נחמ ן דו ידסון
- Source
- Kfar Chabad — 039, p. 11