Why does the author reject the explanation that some rabbinic statements about nature merely reflect the science of their time?
Menachem Mendel Brod argues that such statements appear not only in aggadah but also as the basis of specific halachic rulings. In his reasoning, declaring them mistaken therefore also calls into question the reliability of the halacha based on them. He acknowledges that similar explanations appear in some Rishonim, but considers this extension of their approach unacceptable.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«זו היתה רק דוגמא לסכנה שבנסיונות־הסבר מהסוג הזה.»
- Author
- מנחם מענדל ברוד
- Source
- Kfar Chabad — 101, p. 12