When does a new ruling of a beit din apply only prospectively, and when does it reveal a past error?
If a later beit din weighs the same arguments differently, its ruling applies prospectively: people previously had to follow the court of their time. If an argument emerges that would certainly have changed the earlier court's ruling, the new decision establishes that the earlier ruling was mistaken. A change in ruling therefore does not by itself mean that past conduct requires atonement.
Quote from the source«ושני הצדדים תלויים, בסיבה הגורמת לפסק דין זה:»
- Author
- כ״ק אדמו״ר שליט״א
- Source
- Kfar Chabad — 099, p. 9