Why does teshuvah remove punishment from Heaven but not a human court's death sentence?
The article considers the explanation that a court cannot know the heart, as well as the Noda BiYehuda's view that canceling punishment following a declaration of repentance would undermine judicial deterrence. The author finds these explanations insufficient and argues that a human court, under Torah law, judges the external deed itself. Teshuvah therefore cleanses the person with regard to heavenly punishment but does not remove the basis for punishment by the earthly court.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«תשובת אדם מועילה לתקן את החטא בכל הקשור לעונשי שמים בלבד»
- Author
- רבי יואל כהן
- Source
- אור וחיות - מעיינותיך — or10, p. 3