Why is a dry lulav invalid while leaving the species unbound does not invalidate the mitzvah?
The text distinguishes an embellishment added to a mitzvah from beauty that constitutes its essential completeness. Binding the lulav is an additional adornment, whereas the required hadar of the four species belongs to the mitzvah’s very form. Their union and movement in different directions express that the world’s diversity has one source in God.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«ונראה דיש נוי שהוא תוספת על המצוה, ויש הדר שהוא גוף שלמות המצוה»
- Author
- רבי מאיר צבי ברגמן
- Source
- דרכי אורה — דרכי אורה — sukkos darchei oiru lashon kodesh 5787, p. 2