May an etrog with a missing piece be used after the first day of Sukkot?
Invalidity due to a missing piece or failure to meet the requirement of complete taking applies only on the first day. Nevertheless, whole species should be preferred to beautify the mitzvah. The author explains that a conspicuous defect detracts from its beauty, whereas a very small deficiency does not necessarily prevent a beautiful fulfillment of the mitzvah.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«כל הפסול מדין חסר או לקיחה תמה - אינו פסול כי אם ביום הראשון.»
- Author
- הרה״ג יצחק שלמה פייגנבוים
- Source
- בשבילי דשא — בשבילי דשא — sukkos beshvilei deshe lashon kodesh 5787, p. 7