Must one stand for Modim Derabbanan?
The article cites the ruling of Yechaveh Daat that one must stand for Modim Derabbanan because bowing is performed while standing. The author connects this with the majority view requiring a full bow; under the view of the Bach and his supporters, who require only a slight inclination, he sees possible grounds for answering while seated. However, when others are standing and bowing, he observes that remaining seated appears contrary to the purpose of joining their thanksgiving.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«מפני שחייה זו כתב בשו"ת יחוה דעת שצריך לעמוד במודים דרבנן»
- Author
- הרב יוסף־שמחה גינזבורג
- Source
- התקשרות — 1214hit744, p. 6