Does it violate Ashkenazi custom if a child is named after someone deceased while a living relative has the same name?
The author understands the cited reply from the Rebbe to mean that the concern is the intention to name a child after a living ancestor, rather than the mere coincidence of names. In the case discussed, the child was named after someone deceased without knowing that a living grandmother had the same name; the reply says that apparently this does not violate the custom.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«ובפרט, שלא ידע שיש אימו זקנתו בחיים ששמה כך»
- Author
- הרב לוי הלוי פישער
- Source
- התקשרות — 1261hit764, p. 4