How does the article’s author derive from the verse that attacks on three animal species establish muad status for all animals?
Rabbi Yehoshua Menachem Neuhoyzer proposes that the special exclusion of humans from muad status after attacks on three animal species makes sense only if that status extends to other animal species. If the status were always confined to the species already attacked, excluding humans would add nothing. He therefore treats the difference between “ki yigach” and “ki yigof” as a textual source for the general rule concerning three species. He explains that the wording about extending the status from humans to animals expresses this broader principle, rather than only the greater difficulty of attacking a human.
Quote from the source«ומדיוקא דקרא נלמד כי לשאר הבהמות אכן כן נעשה מועד.»
- Author
- הרה"ת יהושע מנחם שי' נויהויזר
- Source
- התמים (בית משיח) — hat31, p. 17