Why does one tribe's atonement depend on the others in the communal offering for idolatry discussed here?
The Rogatchover Gaon connects this to Israel having heard the prohibition of idolatry directly from God while existing as an indivisible whole. Consequently, in the communal atonement procedure discussed, the absence of atonement for even one tribe prevents atonement for all. In the other communal sins described, each tribe is treated separately.
Quote from the source«ואם אין כפרה אפי' על שבט אחד, ה"ז מעכב את הכפרה לכל בני ישראל»
- Author
- הרב יוסף רוזין
- Source
- התמים (בית משיח) — hat35, p. 14