Why do Rambam and Ramban describe the enumeration in Halachot Gedolot differently?
Rambam criticizes Halachot Gedolot for counting Sabbath violation both as a prohibition and among punishments, whereas Ramban challenges that reading of the book. הרי״פ פערלא explains that they had different textual versions. The version used by Rambam actually contained what he quoted.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«שהרמב"ם והרמב"ן החזיקו גירסאות שונות של דברי הבה"ג»
- Author
- הרי"פ פערלא
- Source
- התמים (בית משיח) — hat39, p. 16