Can the prophet Eliyahu restore the chain of semikhah?
Ralbach holds that Eliyahu remains literally alive, so his semikhah retains its validity and he will be able to confer it on others. Rabbi Yaakov Beirav argues that Eliyahu’s present existence is spiritual rather than bodily and that his former semikhah has expired. In his view, Eliyahu’s future appearance therefore does not remove the need for another way to restore semikhah.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«אבל הרלב"ח סבר שאליהו הנביא עדיין חי בפשטות»
- Author
- הרלב"ח; רבי יעקב בירב
- Source
- התמים (בית משיח) — hat41, p. 17