How was singing during the Nine Days handled in the accounts presented here?
In one account, the Rebbe objected to singing during these days and instructed the organizers to ask a rabbi how to conduct a children's gathering; the rabbi directed them to refrain from singing even during prayer. In another account, the Rebbe encouraged the congregation to sing, although on one occasion they stopped when he did not encourage them. The text records different instances of conduct and a specific instruction to consult a rabbi, but does not formulate a general permission to sing during the Nine Days.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«למחרת העיר, שלא הי' עליהם לשיר בימים אלה וגם הורה לשאול רב כיצד לנהוג בכינוס הילדים שיתקיים ביום ב'.»
- Author
- Редакция «קבצים שבועיים»
- Source
- קבצים שבועיים — גאולה ומשיח — הירידה חלק מהעליה, p. 21