Why does the author of Peninei HaTanya suggest checking earlier understandings of the Rebbe’s discourses when their meaning is disputed?
The author cites a rule about a scholar reporting a received teaching: reporting it only after a personally relevant case arises creates a problem of vested interest. Applying this to disputes over the Rebbe’s continued life, he argues that later interpretations may adjust the words to fit what people witnessed. He therefore proposes recalling earlier understandings of the discourses, which he considers less affected by this interest.
Quote from the source«אם קודם שבא מעשה לידו, שומעין לו, ואם אחר שבא מעשה לידו, אין שומעין לו.»
- Author
- הרחלוי"צ שי' גינזבורג
- Source
- קבצים שבועיים — גאולה ומשיח — ראש השנה לאמונה, p. 19