What does Rabbi Shmelke’s story teach about prayer before developing new Torah insights?
Rabbi Shmelke told his students that without concentration during the blessings Ahavah Rabbah and Atah Chonen, a person could not produce a true new Torah insight that day. One student challenged this with his solution to a question about a damaged esophagus, but the teacher exposed its flaw: an argument relying on a sound inner membrane cannot apply when that membrane is itself punctured. The story connects the search for a true explanation with prayer and shows that a plausible argument still requires careful scrutiny.
Quote from the source«מי שאינו מכוון בברכת אהבה רבה ואתה חונן, לא יוכל לחדש ביום זה דבר אמת בתורה.»
- Author
- ר' שמעלקי מניקלשבורג
- Source
- מעיינותיך - למחשבת חב''ד — 33, p. 10