Can sincere faith coexist with a mistaken understanding of fundamental beliefs?
The article distinguishes the inner strength of faith from the correctness of its conscious content. It cites people in the era of the Rishonim, including great Torah scholars, who believed that the Creator had a body: the strength of their faith did not eliminate their conceptual error. It also stresses that once the halachic ruling was established, such a view contradicted the foundations of faith; sincerity does not make a belief’s content correct.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«משמע, האמונה הנשמתית כפי שהיא משתקפת בתודעת האדם אינה בהכרח שוללת חסרון דברים יסודיים בעיקרי הדת גם אצל גדולי ישראל אמיתיים.»
- Author
- הרב אריה לייב קפלן ע"ה
- Source
- מעיינותיך - למחשבת חב''ד — 55, p. 5