Does a defect in an etrog matter if it is difficult to see?
For beauty defects that can disqualify even in a tiny amount, what matters is whether the defect is visible when the etrog is held and examined normally. According to the cited Mabit, a minute defect requiring prolonged scrutiny does not detract from hadar. For lekichah tamah, however, Rabbi Akiva Eiger considers an actual lack of completeness significant even when it is not apparent in such an examination.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«אבל אם אינו נראה לעין מחמת דקותו וצריך להסתכל בו הרבה כדי שיהיה נרגש בראיה לא נפיק מכלל הדר»
- Author
- רבי שמעיה לעוו
- Source
- לב שומע — לב שומע — Ha'azinu 5787, p. 25
- Parsha
- Haazinu