Why does admitting a debt of barley when wheat is claimed count as a partial admission according to Rabban Gamliel, but not according to the Sages?
The Rebbe explains that Rabban Gamliel considers the substance of the claim: it concerns money, and the admitted barley debt represents part of the value claimed for the wheat. He therefore requires the defendant to take the oath associated with a partial admission. The Sages focus on the actual subject of the debt: barley and wheat are different kinds, so this admission does not acknowledge part of the stated claim and does not require that oath.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«טענו חיטים והודה לו בשעורים פטור ורבן גמליאל מחייב»
- Author
- הרבי
- Source
- עיתון כי קרוב - מעיינותיך — Ki karov 08-E, p. 15