How does the meaning of cessation explain the dispute about intention in Shabbat labor?
The article presents the Rebbe's explanation that Rabbi Yehudah emphasizes the act of labor itself, so the absence of its usual purpose or intention does not remove its conflict with Shabbat rest. Rabbi Shimon emphasizes the inner content of purposeful labor, melechet machshevet, and the absence of that content changes its status. As a tentative addition, the author suggests that Rabbi Yehudah gives intention a role primarily in excluding extreme cases, such as an act that only causes damage.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ולרבי שמעון, היות וגדרה של מלאכה בשבת היא "מלאכת מחשבת"»
- Author
- הרב משה שילת
- Source
- עיתון כי קרוב - מעיינותיך — Ki karov 11-E, p. 14