Does the promise to eliminate dangerous animals mean they will disappear or stop causing harm?
Rabbi Yehudah understands the promise as the complete removal of dangerous animals, while Rabbi Shimon understands it as ending the harm they cause. The Rogatchover Gaon connects this dispute to their understanding of elimination: removing an entity itself or removing its harmful quality. According to Rabbi Shimon, the animal can therefore remain in existence while its danger has been eliminated.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«רבי יהודה אומר מעבירם מן העולם, רבי שמעון אומר משביתן שלא יזיקו»
- Author
- הגאון הרוגצ'ובי
- Source
- עיתון כי קרוב - מעיינותיך — Ki karov 11-E, p. 14