Why does Rabbi Yehudah require burning chametz while the Sages allow other methods of disposal?
The Rogatchover Gaon explains the dispute through the meaning of eliminating chametz. Rabbi Yehudah requires ending the existence of the substance itself, so burning is necessary, with the remaining ash considered a new entity. The Sages consider it sufficient to remove the qualities that allow the chametz to be eaten or used, so crumbling and scattering it in the wind or casting it into the sea also qualify.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«רבי יהודה אומר אין ביעור חמץ אלא שריפה, וחכמים אומרים אף מפרר וזורה לרוח או מטיל לים»
- Author
- הגאון הרוגצ'ובי
- Source
- עיתון כי קרוב - מעיינותיך — Ki karov 11-E, p. 14