How does the dispute over the population of an ir hanidachat relate to the individual and the community?
The article presents the Rebbe's explanation: Rabbi Yoshiyah gives decisive weight to the communal dimension, while Rabbi Yonatan preserves the status of individuals for longer. Rabbi Yoshiyah therefore places an ir hanidachat in the range of ten to one hundred people, while Rabbi Yonatan gives the range of one hundred to the majority of a tribe. These thresholds reflect different approaches to when a collection of individuals becomes a city and then a community.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«לרבי יאשיה עניין לציבור מכריע ולרבי יונתן עניין היחיד מכריע.»
- Author
- הרבי
- Source
- עיתון כי קרוב - מעיינותיך — Ki karov 12-1-E, p. 7