God showed Moshe Rabbi Akiva's martyrdom and said 'such was My original plan'. Could the Creator have 'erred' and changed His plan?
The Talmud (Menachot 29) relates that Moshe, seeing Rabbi Akiva's martyrdom, cried out 'Is this the reward?!', and God replied: 'Be silent, such was My original plan.' Rashi cites the Midrash Yalkut: at first the Creator intended to create the world with the attribute of Justice alone, but seeing that such a world could not last long, He tempered Justice with Mercy. The Vilna Gaon explains: the Midrash does not imply God changed His intention - the world is still founded on Justice as planned. But without free choice there can be no justice: if every action were immediately rewarded or punished, freedom itself would lose meaning. Justice tempered with mercy means the consequences of actions are not obvious and do not arrive instantly; this lets a person decide for himself - and becomes the precondition for judging him for his deeds.
Quote from the source«Всевышний может осуществлять правосудие, если Он прежде проявил милосердие»
- Author
- раввин Носон Вайс
- Source
- Love Doing Good — journal-178, p. 4