If the Torah was accepted under coercion, why were transgressions punished before Purim?
Tosfos explains that rejecting idolatry was accepted voluntarily, so its violation was punishable; coercion at Sinai prevented the people from withdrawing in fear after their initial willing acceptance. Midrash Tanchuma distinguishes the willingly accepted Written Torah, whose violations were punishable, from the demanding Oral Torah accepted under coercion. The Ramban and Rashba explain that Torah observance was a condition of living in the Land of Israel, so the coercion claim applied only after exile. At Purim, the people accepted the Torah out of love even for life in exile, ending that claim.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«On Purim they accepted the Torah out of love even in the Diaspora.»
- Author
- TOSFOS; MIDRASH TANCHUMA; RAMBAN; RASHBA
- Source
- Parsha.net — Terumah58, p. 6
- Parsha
- Terumah