Why do a questioner's circumstances and wishes matter when giving a halakhic ruling?
Rabbi Naftali Bar-Ilan explains that a specific ruling requires familiarity with all the circumstances and may also take the questioner's wishes into account. He gives the example of attending a wedding during the year of mourning for a parent, saying that halakhic support can be found both for attending and for being excused. He therefore prefers answering personal questions to issuing general public judgments on current events.
Quote from the source«In order to rule on a specific matter, one has to be familiar with all the conditions.»
- Author
- Rabbi Naftali Bar-Ilan
- Source
- Parsha.net — Terumah68, p. 9
- Parsha
- Terumah