Why do completely identical accounts from two witnesses arouse suspicion?
The Netziv cites the Jerusalem Talmud: people do not normally describe the same event in exactly the same words. Word-for-word agreement suggests that their testimony may have been coordinated and rehearsed. He thus explains “shnayim eidim” as witnesses who corroborate an event without appearing to be exact duplicates of each other.
Quote from the source«We suspect them of lying because no two people are going to relate a n incident exactly the same way.»
- Author
- Netziv
- Source
- Parsha.net — Terumah76, p. 5
- Parsha
- Terumah