How do commentators explain why both the priestly garments and tzara'as are associated with atonement for the same grave sins?
Rashi explains that the garments atone for the nation's responsibility for murder and sexual immorality, rather than the perpetrator's guilt; Tosfos questions this explanation in light of collective responsibility. Another explanation quoted by Tosfos distinguishes an actual offense from an act compared to it, such as humiliating someone, which is likened to murder. The Rosh similarly distinguishes arrogance that leads to a sinful act from inward arrogance. The Maharsha offers a different distinction: the garments atone for unintentional grave sins, while tzara'as applies to intentional ones when judicial punishment is unavailable.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«If someone actually killed, then he is punished with Tzara'as.»
- Author
- RASHI; TOSFOS; ROSH; MAHARSHA
- Source
- Parsha.net — Tetzave71, p. 5
- Parsha
- Tetzaveh