Why prove that the liviyatan is a kosher fish if the righteous are already said to eat it?
Rabbi Yossi ben Dormaskis derives from verses in Iyov that the liviyatan has scales and fins. The Maharsha explains that this establishes specifically that it is a fish, rather than another kosher aquatic creature such as a gigantic goose. The Maharitz Chiyut explains that the promised feast alone would not establish its ordinary kosher status, since a special permission for that occasion might have been assumed. Such a temporary permission, a hora’at sha’ah, is discussed regarding future slaughter with the liviyatan’s fins and does not mean that Torah law changes. Rabbi Yossi’s teaching therefore establishes that the liviyatan is kosher without any exceptional permission.
Quote from the source«Rather, perhaps it is a different type of kosher creature that lives in the water, such as a gigantic goose, which is not a fish.»
- Author
- Rabbi Moshe Newman
- Source
- Parsha.net — Tetzave79, p. 10
- Parsha
- Tetzaveh