Did the proposal to “hide” Mishlei and Kohelet mean excluding them from Scripture or withdrawing them from circulation?
Moshe Rosenberg explains that the discussion in Shabbat may concern withdrawing already accepted sacred books from circulation because of apparent contradictions, whereas Avot d'Rabbi Noson discusses their inclusion in Scripture. He leaves open whether the sources describe the same episode. Rav Shnayer Leiman clarifies that the verb ganaz itself implies sanctity and challenges the use of the book of remedies as an example of a clearly nonsacred book. He also notes that a book could be written through divine inspiration without being included in Tanakh.
The source brings differing opinions.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«Books or objects lacking kedushah are disposed via the verbs saraf and ba'er.»
- Author
- Moshe Rosenberg; Rav Shnayer Leiman
- Source
- Parsha.net — Vaeira58, p. 7
- Parsha
- Vaera