Why shouldn’t every distinction in Gemara automatically be explained as two separate laws?
Rav Chaim distinguished between two laws to resolve actual contradictions, but copying this method where no contradiction exists imposes a predetermined scheme on the material. Malbim’s explanation provides an example: Pharaoh’s advisers treated his dreams as separate messages, while Yosef recognized their unified meaning. Analysis should follow the text and allow for either distinction or unity.
Quote from the source«Logical sevaras are certainly valuable but they all have to flow from within the sugya and not to be imposed from without.»
- Author
- Rabbi Hershel Schachter
- Source
- Parsha.net — Vaeira81, p. 6
- Parsha
- Vaera