Can a shepherd be made to pay for a predator attack on the grounds that he might have saved the flock miraculously?
If a hired shepherd leaves the flock and a predator attacks in his absence, liability depends on an assessment of whether he could actually have protected the animals. Compensation cannot be demanded automatically by invoking David's miraculous victory over the lion and bear. The shepherd can answer that if the owner deserved a miracle, it could have occurred without anyone present, as in the account of Rabbi Chanina ben Dossa's goats.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«That evening each goat indeed came home carrying a bear on its horns.»
- Author
- RABBI MENDEL WEINBACH
- Source
- Parsha.net — VayakhelPekudei62, p. 7
- Parsha
- Vayakhel