Why is belief in Moshe's prophecy based on Sinai rather than on his miracles?
The Rambam explains that belief based on signs leaves room for doubt because an extraordinary act might be attributed to magic. At Sinai, the people themselves saw and heard the revelation rather than relying on someone else's testimony. This direct witness therefore provided a sufficient foundation for belief in Moshe's prophecy.
Quote from the source«It was based on the revelation at Sinai, for it was our own eyes that saw (and not a stranger's) and our ears that heard (and not someone else's) the fire, thunder, and lightning . . .»
- Author
- Ramba"m
- Source
- Parsha.net — Yisro56, p. 14
- Parsha
- Yitro