Why is Cain’s reply, “Am I my brother’s keeper?” considered a challenge to God?
In the cited Midrash, Cain is not merely evading the question but trying to place responsibility for Abel’s death on God. He argues that God, the keeper of all creatures, should have protected his brother. His question becomes a way to accuse someone else instead of acknowledging his own responsibility.
Quote from the source«By responding with a question, Cain brazenly faulted the Almighty Himself for Abel's murder.»
- Author
- Rabbi Weinreb
- Source
- Parsha.net — Yisro74, p. 5
- Parsha
- Yitro