Why can a punishment become forbidden when people perceive it as cruelty?
In the cited explanation of the Chazon Ish, extraordinary measures involving death apply only when divine providence is evident and people understand the punishment as correcting evil. When that understanding is absent, such actions are perceived as violence and aggression. They then defeat their purpose and are therefore forbidden.
Quote from the source«As a result, he rules that they are counterproductive, and therefore forbidden.»
- Author
- Chazon Ish
- Source
- Parsha.net — AchreiKedoshim62, p. 2
- Parsha
- Kedoshim