Why can a song that needs no melody be considered a higher form of song?
Abarbanel distinguishes a song whose special quality lies in its music and melody from poetic words that open the heart by themselves. He places the Song at the Sea in the first category and Shir HaShirim in the second. The second is higher because its words have their effect without musical accompaniment.
Quote from the source«Shir Hashirim which are poetic expressions which open up the heart, they don't need song,»
- Author
- Ababernel
- Source
- Parsha.net — Pesach77, p. 6