Why must atonement for wronging another person be substantial and visible?
Rabbi Shalom Carmy proposes combining the Ramban's and Ralbag's insights: unresolved injustice obstructs spiritual life, but unseen punishment from Heaven does not sufficiently restore damaged relationships. The sacrifice, together with the applicable monetary penalties, provides public resolution of the offense against God and one's neighbor. The asham's substantial cost conveys the offense's gravity and the seriousness of atonement, helping resolve conflict and resentment.
Quote from the source«Leaving the sinner's punishment to Heaven is inadequate, because unseen expiation does not restore the social balance that has been violated.»
- Author
- Rabbi Shalom Carmy
- Source
- Parsha.net — Vayikra56, p. 13
- Parsha
- Vayikra