How do the Ramban and Ralbag differ in assessing the weight of the asham offering?
The Ramban connects the name “asham” with desolation and sees the prescribed high cost of most such offerings as indicating the offense's gravity. The Ralbag, by contrast, regards the asham as less weighty than the chatat: an asham taluy addresses uncertainty, whereas the chatat concerns unintentional offenses whose deliberate commission constitutes a grave crime. For the Ralbag, allowing atonement for monetary offenses helps resolve conflict and remove an obstacle to spiritual perfection.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«The RaLBa"G, however, regards the asham as a less weighty sacrifice than the cht'at.»
- Author
- RaMBa"N; RaLBa"G
- Source
- Parsha.net — Vayikra56, p. 13
- Parsha
- Vayikra