How did the Or HaChaim expose a man who denied receiving money for safekeeping?
A merchant entrusted his host with a bag of money, but after Shabbat the host denied receiving it. When it emerged that there were no witnesses and the handover had occurred beneath a tree, Rabbi Chaim ben Attar sent the merchant to bring the tree to court. He then asked the defendant whether the merchant had reached the tree; the man replied that it was too far away, revealing his knowledge of the handover location. The rabbi pointed out the contradiction, and the host confessed and returned the money: the story shows how a perceptive question can expose a lie and restore justice.
Quote from the source«מֶ ְרחָ ק ַרב מִ כָּאן וְ עַ ד הָ עֵ ץ»
- Author
- חיים בן עטר
- Source
- המשגיח — המשגיח — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 3
- Parsha
- Vayetzei