Why do the four species require “לכם” if stolen items are already excluded as a mitzvah performed through a transgression?
Tosafot offer an explanation in which the disqualification of a mitzvah performed through a transgression is rabbinic, making an independent verse necessary. Mishnat de-Rabbi Akiva and other cited sources discuss another case: even under the opinion being considered that permits taking a non-Jew’s property, the object still does not qualify as “yours” for the mitzvah. This is a conditional argument about the need for the verse, rather than an independent permission to take another person’s property.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«די"ל דמצהב"ע הוא מדרבנן»
- Author
- Редакция «הואיל משה»
- Source
- הואיל משה — הואיל משה — hoil moshe parshas vayeitzei 5787, p. 9
- Parsha
- Vayetzei