Can a rabbi's explanation of his conduct be assumed to reveal all his reasons?
Rav Mordechai Schein explains that Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky could give a true reason for his conduct without revealing his other reasons. He sometimes gave different people different explanations, and some responses were admonitions or figurative remarks rather than purely legal rulings. His answers therefore need to be understood in their context and according to the kind of response he was giving.
Quote from the source«ולפעמים לאדם אחד אמר איזה טעם, ולשני אמר טעם אחר.»
- Author
- הרב מרדכי שיין שליט"א
- Source
- עלים — עלים — alim-vayaitzei-5787-aleh-zayis bw — Vayeitzei 5787, p. 2
- Parsha
- Vayetzei