Why did the animals perish in the Flood if they have no free choice?
Rav Yosef Salant explains that before the Flood, animals were completely subject to human beings, whose conduct affected their nature. Human corruption therefore corrupted the animals, although they did not choose evil themselves. Their destruction is explained as removing the evil embedded in their nature, rather than punishing an independent choice.
Quote from the source«An animal does not have בחירה like a human being, but rather the human being’s behaviour simply affected the way the animals behaved.»
- Author
- ר' יוסף סלנט
- Source
- Taking the Parshiyos With Us — Taking the Parshiyos With Us — copy — Noach 5787, p. 5
- Parsha
- Noach