Does a person have free will if they have a strong inclination toward wrongdoing from birth?
Citing the Ramchal, the author explains that free will does not mean having no strong urges. Even a small capacity to resist means that sin is not inevitable. Eisav's inclination toward idolatry before birth therefore did not prevent him from fighting it as he grew older. Urges can also be directed toward good, as in the example of someone channeling an inclination toward bloodshed into serving as a mohel.
Quote from the source«The answer is (as the Ramchal points out in Derech Hashem 1;3;8) that free will does not mean that one has no urges.»
- Author
- D Fine; Ramchal
- Source
- ליקוטי שמואל — ליקוטי שמואל — parashat toldos 5787, p. 14
- Parsha
- Toldot