When does liability for a fine arise: when the act occurs or when the case is adjudicated?
Rabbi Yonah holds that liability arises when the act occurs, while Rabbi Yosi holds that it arises upon adjudication. The text examines how both positions account for cases in which the young woman's father dies or she reaches the bogeret stage between the act and adjudication, citing specific scriptural interpretations.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ר' יונה אומר שחיוב קנס הוא משעת המעשה ור' יוסי אומר משעת העמדה בדין»
- Author
- ר' יונה; ר' יוסי
- Source
- מה בדף ירושלמי — מה בדף ירושלמי — Toldos 5787, p. 2
- Parsha
- Toldot